I’m 13 years old and middle school is a torment. I’m not one of the “popular” kids. I don’t get invited to parties on the weekends – dances in cleaned out garages with parents distantly close inside. Okay, so I went to one. I remember dancing with a new kid, probably because he was too dumb to know I wasn’t worth knowing. I loved the feeling of someone’s hands other than my own around my waist. The flirting with adolescent hormones that had just started to surge. But my strict Mennonite church background ruined the moment – You’re dancing too close. Your parents will be mad. You’re not allowed to date till you’re 16 anyway. STOP. Shame. STOP. Guilt. You’re doing something wrong. But was I? The fabric of my entire adolescence and early adulthood was being laid out before my eyes, and I didn’t even know it.
My first kiss happened exactly like it does in the movies. Boy meets girl. They fall in love. It’s a picture perfect exchange of feelings. Or at least, that’s the way I always imagined it would go because you know a kiss is a sacred thing. You don’t just give those away to anyone. But I did. Two in one night. Spin the Bottle. As if it could get any less classy. The second boy and I “dated” for a whopping two weeks, meeting up just one other time to make out before we “broke up.” It’s tragic, isn’t it? Firsts hold this hype that they’re going to be phenomenal, change your life. But they don’t, other than to let you down. And so firsts become seconds become thirds become I better stop counting because to keep track most certainly means I’m a slut.
Which I wasn’t, of course. A “make out” free spirit, maybe. Cuz, gosh, that was fun. Kissing someone for the first time was like a brand new rollercoaster ride. Exhilarating, full of adrenaline, and never knowing quite what came next. No one kisses quite the same. It’s like trying a new flavor of ice cream, one that will never be replicated with the next. Each is it’s own sort of delicious experiment. So, I kissed a lot. And, I got good at it.
Still, to my great pride, I made it all the way through college with my virginity still in tact. Cuz as any good Christian girl knows, that’s what matters. Nobody wants to buy the cow when they can get the milk for free… Okay. So it was probably relayed in different terms, like, remain pure or become damaged goods. There’s a reason I was given a “purity ring” in my early teens. And yet another reason I stopped wearing it. How much purity did you have to lose before you no longer had any hope for the blessed marriage they preached? Luckily, this message came up short in regards to my one and only but… I gave up plenty along the way.
So let’s talk about it shall we? “The first time.” Which time? The first that I didn’t choose or the one that I did. A juxtaposition of two boys with very different roles in my life, but whose lasting effect on me would be ultimately the same. Moments in which lust was large and respect was an illusion. I told boy number two about boy number one before we “did it.” We’d been friends for years, so he was supposed to care about the guy who had taken my consent for foreplay and pushed it too far. The guy who silenced me. The guy who hurt me. The guy who forced his way to what he wanted. But, he too only cared about getting far enough. And I had trusted him for years so I let him. But long drawn out friendships are not the pathways to love, they are just an excuse to get physical enough to try.
I’m in college in a new town all by myself, knowing no one. So I Skype with one of my best guy friends from high school, who happens to be a really great Christian guy. You know, the one who always lead worship on Sunday mornings, the one who bought me a devotional for my birthday. So, it starts innocently enough. Except, as I said, I’m lonely. I don’t think I’ll ever hear “Sexy B*tch” by David Guetta again without cringing. You can let your imagination figure out what happens when you combine said music and video chat. It’s probably what you think it is. Which also turned into what it should have never been. Getting physical. In person. Turning something trusted into something more. And with it, tainting once again the idea that Christian boys and girls remain pure at all times. Looking back, it’s probably why I wrapped a lot of hope up in that boy. The idea that he’d save me from myself. That yes, we had faltered, but if it ended up meaning something more that would lessen the fall. Alas, it didn’t and I continued on most certainly tainted.
So here I was, a twenty-something with way too extensive of a history for my very conservative Christian upbringing. (And let’s not forget that mounting pile of shame). Mix that in with a little alcohol and a whole lot of longing for the real deal and I found myself in one hell of a mess.
And gosh, messes are fun at the time. You know you shouldn’t get involved but there’s something kind of intriguing about rolling around where you don’t belong. So I’m in my mid-twenties and I try to turn “fun and crazy” into something like love. It’s the most physical relationship I’ve ever been in to this point. I’m 24 and never been on birth control, but now I am. I crave him like a drug. I guess, that’s what lust is. And eventually it becomes so deep that you convince yourself it is love. And, ironically, I still believe it was. Love on steroids, maybe. Jacked up, found through less than normal circumstances, and never sustainable in reality. I fell hard. And all the while that little voice in the back of my head was screaming – STOP. “This is wrong. This is not what you want.” But, I did. I wanted it. So much so that I “broke up” with him over a year later only to keep sleeping with him while he “dated” someone else. I have never fallen farther. I held on tighter instead of letting go because I was too damaged to believe I could come back from this.
Every scenario took me one step farther in a pattern that began with that first dance. Do something. Feel guilty. Do something more. Feel guilty again. Have something done to you, blame it on yourself for being in that situation in the first place. Good Christian girls don’t put themselves in those kind of situations. Good Christian girls don’t let it go too far. Good Christian girls don’t flirt with their bodies. Good Christian girls don’t fall for the wrong boy. Good Christian girls save themselves for marriage. Feel guilty? You should. Feel worthless? You should. Feel unworthy of love? You should.
And, I did. Sometimes, I still do. That’s the thing with patterns. Even when they reach their end the fabric of their influence is so deeply woven into who you are that you sometimes forget it stopped defining you a long time ago. Or rather, that it never did.
Purity culture tried to barricade my self-worth.
It didn’t preach a message of grace, instead it was laden with fear and shame – holding hands will lead to feeling up will lead to this will lead to sex. So don’t hold hands, lest it lead you down the path of sin. Save yourself. (One message I once heard in a high school youth group). Or another – once you give a piece of yourself away you can never get it back. Which is true, in the way that I can’t take back the kisses I’ve given or the beds I’ve slept in. But false in the way in which it says who I am or what I’m worth. I remember far too many messages about what we shouldn’t do, and yet little if anything about what to do if we did.
I’m fifteen or so and at a high school youth conference somewhere in the hills. And of course, I’m googly eyed for a boy. He’s a couple years older. And I remember simply leaning against him, holding his hand and my youth pastor’s wife pointing to the ring on her finger and saying “you don’t have a license to do that.” As if I had to be married to feel something.
I was feeling it then. I had teenage hormones raging through my body, but instead I was supposed to just ignore them because it was the “right thing to do.” As if attraction was wrong. That yes, God designed sexual desire but you better learn to hold it at bay. At least until the day my Knight in Shining Armor came riding in on his horse and whisked me off my feet, gave me a wedding ring, and called me his wife. Then I would be “allowed.”
I’m here to say BULLSHIT. And not to say that I don’t believe in God’s design for marriage and for sex. Lord knows the battle I’ve had to endure overcoming all that guilt. But I do believe that pile of guilt would have been more like a small dust mound if I hadn’t grown up believing that sexual sin was the absolute worst kind. I know I’m not the first to denounce purity culture. It was a movement largely present in the 90s and early 2000s, and many an article has come out of about its affects since then. I’m simply speaking to my own experience. I could have saved myself a whole lot of pain if the adults in my life had simply been real. Real honest. Real open. Real accepting about the reality of the desires I had that were what God created them to be… natural.
I have spent years overcoming the shame I felt as a result of that message burned into my brain.
I dated a guy in college who was a born again Christian. Meaning, he had a past. He wasn’t a virgin, he used to drink, etc. I met him after. We became friends in a very protected bubble and started dating. I kissed him, once, after a road trip. He told me later on that we shouldn’t do that. And instead of feeling like, “AWW! Here it is! The perfect godly man who respects me and wants to wait that they’ve been telling me about my whole life!” I again, felt shame. Because, I wanted to. Because, I did.
The reality is I like to kiss. Hell, my husband and I did a lot more than that before he asked me to be his wife.
I am not damned because I entered my wedding night “less whole.”
But, the pattern remains. So I’m working through it. It’s taken a lot of time and a lot of counseling. It’s caused strife in my marriage simply because something I want to do for my husband, once upon a time, made me feel dirty. Made me feel less then. But those choices do not define me. And they certainly don’t factor in to my worthiness in God’s kingdom.
Take Rahab for example. She was a prostitute, yet she found favor with God. He loved her and protected her despite her choices because she had faith in Who He was and what He said.
I may have been raised in purity culture, but I was also raised with a faith in the true God. The One who says He loves me in spite of my mistakes, or rather, because of them. He created me uniquely and perfectly in His image, sexual desires and all. And while I acknowledge the reasons why sex was designed for marriage, I also know that I don’t have to carry shame because my first experiences were outside it.
I have “grace” tattooed on the inside of my wrist because that is truly the character of God that spoke the most to me during those tumulterous years of struggle between what I desired and who I thought I should be. It is not about what I’ve done. He loved me while I was still a sinner, which lets be honest, I still am. But because I truly believe in Who He says He is, I am saved from the pain that comes with those choices. And I am certainly free from the guilt that Purity Culture wanted to tack on as extra penance.
I am not damaged goods. My worthiness as a wife and a mother are not tainted because of the choices I made in my teens and twenties. On the contrary, God has used those experiences to reveal His character to me in extremely beautiful ways. As a Healer, as a Protector, as a Father, as a Lover, as a Friend. One who values me, accepts me, and calls me as His own.
At times I still wish I could rewrite the story, but instead, I’ll use it. To serve as a testimony to the Truth.
My chains are gone, I’ve been set free.